When it’s time to replace your roof, the big question becomes metal roof vs shingles—which will protect your home better and give you the most value? Both roofing systems are popular choices for New England homes, but they differ in terms of cost, longevity, and efficiency.
In this guide, the experts at Adam Vaillancourt Roofing break down everything you need to know about a metal roof vs asphalt shingles, including real-world performance, lifespan, and pricing. By understanding the pros and cons, we can help you make an informed decision that is right for your home and budget.
Before comparing the two, schedule a roof inspection to learn how your current roof is performing and whether it’s time for an upgrade.
Asphalt Shingles: Pros, Cons & Typical Costs
What Are Asphalt Shingles?
When people debate a metal roof vs shingles, asphalt shingles are usually the starting point. They’re the most common roofing material in America, made from fiberglass mats coated with asphalt and mineral granules.
An asphalt shingle roof typically lasts 20 to 30 years, offering solid protection at an affordable price. There are three main types—3-tab, architectural, and premium—each designed to suit different styles and budgets.
If you’re leaning toward the shingle side of the debate, check out our asphalt shingle roofing services for professional installation and guidance.
Upfront Cost Range
Cost is one of the main reasons asphalt shingles remain so popular. On average, homeowners can expect to pay between $4 and $6 per square foot, including both materials and installation costs. For a typical 2,000-square-foot home, that comes out to roughly $8,000–$12,000.
While that’s significantly more affordable than metal, it’s essential to consider long-term maintenance and replacement costs—especially if you plan to stay in your home for decades.
Advantages of Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles offer plenty of advantages for homeowners seeking value and versatility:
- Affordable installation: One of the most cost-effective roofing materials available.
- Ease of repair: Individual shingles can be replaced without tearing off large sections of the roof.
- Variety of styles: Available in a wide range of colors, textures, and profiles.
- Reliable protection: Performs well in moderate weather and resists wind and rain when installed correctly.
- Familiarity: Many roofing professionals specialize in asphalt shingles, ensuring consistent quality and performance.
Disadvantages of Asphalt Shingles
Despite their popularity, asphalt shingles have limitations worth noting:
- Shorter lifespan: Generally lasts 20–30 years, much less than metal roofing.
- Weather vulnerability: High winds, hail, and ice can damage or loosen shingles, potentially causing significant issues.
- Heat absorption: Dark shingles absorb more sunlight, which raises attic temperatures in the summer.
- Environmental impact: Made from petroleum-based materials, which makes it harder to recycle.
If you live in a region with frequent temperature swings or harsh winters (like New England), these factors can shorten a shingle roof’s lifespan. Routine maintenance and periodic inspections are key to getting the most out of it.
Metal Roofing: Pros, Cons & Cost Factors
What Are Metal Roofs?
Metal roofs are constructed from durable materials, including steel, aluminum, and copper. They come in styles ranging from traditional standing-seam panels to metal shingles that mimic the look of tile or slate.
A well-maintained metal roof can last 40–70 years, offering double (or even triple) the lifespan of asphalt shingles. Beyond longevity, metal roofs offer excellent resistance to snow, rain, wind, and fire, making them an ideal choice for New England homes that are exposed to unpredictable weather conditions.
Explore more about metal roofing systems available through Adam Vaillancourt Roofing.
Upfront Cost Range
When evaluating metal roof vs shingles, cost remains the most significant factor. Installing a metal roof typically costs between $8 and $14 per square foot, depending on the material and the complexity of the roof. For an average 2,000-square-foot home, the total investment can range from $16,000 – $28,000.
While that’s roughly twice the cost of asphalt shingles, metal roofs deliver substantial long-term savings through minimal maintenance, reduced cooling costs, and exceptional durability.
Advantages of Metal Roofing
Metal roofing has earned a reputation for strength and sustainability. Key benefits include:
- Longevity: Can last 40 to 70 years with proper care and maintenance.
- Energy efficiency: Reflects sunlight, helping reduce cooling costs by up to 25%.
- Weather resistance: Performs exceptionally well in snow, ice, and high winds common across New England.
- Fire resistance: Non-combustible and often qualifies for insurance discounts.
- Sustainability: Most panels contain recycled content and are fully recyclable.
These benefits make metal a smart investment for homeowners who prioritize durability, safety, and energy efficiency.
Disadvantages of Metal Roofing
No roofing material is perfect. Before you decide on a metal roof, consider a few trade-offs:
- Higher initial cost: Upfront installation can strain tight budgets.
- Noise: Rain and hail may sound louder on un-insulated metal surfaces.
- Denting risk: Large hail or falling branches can cause cosmetic dents on thinner panels.
- Expansion and contraction: Panels can shift slightly with temperature changes if not properly fastened.
Even with these factors, most roofing experts agree that the pros and cons of a metal roof vs shingles heavily favor metal for long-term homeowners. Modern installation methods and proper insulation minimize most of these concerns.
Side-by-Side Comparison: Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles
Choosing between asphalt shingles and metal roofing becomes easier when you compare their advantages and disadvantages.
Here’s a quick reference guide based on average U.S. data and New England climate conditions:
| Category | Asphalt Shingles | Metal Roofing |
|---|---|---|
| Cost (per sq. ft.) | $4 - $6 | $8 - $14 |
| Typical Lifespan | 20 - 30 years | 40 - 70 years |
| Maintenance Needs | Periodic repairs & granule loss | Minimal: occasional inspections |
| Resale Value / ROI | Moderate return | Higher long-term ROI |
| Energy Efficiency | Moderate; absorbs heat | High; reflects sunlight |
| Durability | Fair in mild climates | Excellent in extreme weather |
| Environmental Impact | Petroleum-based | Recyclable/eco-friendly |
| Aesthetic Variety | Wide range of colors | Modern or classic metal looks |
| Noise Level | Quiet | Slightly louder in rain |
| Weight on Structure | Heavier | Lightweight |
When reviewing these numbers, think about how long you plan to stay in your home.
If you expect to move within the next decade, asphalt shingles may be a more financially sensible choice. But if you’re investing for the next 40 years, metal delivers better lifetime value and fewer repairs.
Ideal Use Cases for Asphalt Shingle Roofing
Asphalt shingles are ideal for homeowners who want a dependable roof that looks great and fits their budget. While they’re not as long-lasting as metal, they’re highly practical in many scenarios.
You might choose asphalt shingles if:
- You plan to move within 5–10 years. The lower upfront cost helps preserve resale value without a major investment.
- Your home has a steep or simple roofline. Asphalt works efficiently on most traditional pitched roofs.
- You live in a moderate climate. Areas with fewer freeze-thaw cycles or severe storms can extend shingle life.
- You prefer a quiet roof. Shingles naturally absorb more sound than metal roofing.
- You want maximum color choice. Asphalt offers more textures and hues than any other material.
If you’re unsure about your current roof’s condition, it’s smart to start with a professional roof inspection. Adam Vaillancourt Roofing provides honest, detailed assessments that help you decide whether a shingle replacement is right for your home.
Ideal Use Cases for Metal Roofing
Metal roofing excels where strength, longevity, and energy savings matter most. Homeowners in regions prone to extreme weather—heavy snowfall, high winds, or large temperature swings—often see the greatest return on this investment.
Consider metal roofing if:
- You plan to stay in your home long-term. A lifespan of up to 70 years means you may never need another replacement.
- You live in an area with severe weather. Metal sheds snow easily and resists hail, ice, and hurricane-level winds.
- Energy efficiency is a priority. Reflective coatings reduce heat absorption and help control utility costs.
- You want low maintenance. No shingle curling, granule loss, or frequent repairs—just occasional inspections.
- You value sustainability. Most metal roofs are made from recycled materials and are 100% recyclable at the end of their life.
For homeowners in New Hampshire, Northern Massachusetts, and Maine, where winters are long and unpredictable, metal roofing offers peace of mind and long-term protection that outlasts nearly any other material.
How to Choose Based on Your Home & Goals
When comparing a metal roof vs shingles, it’s best to focus on your personal goals, not just the price tag. The right roof depends on how long you’ll stay in your home, what kind of climate you face, and how much maintenance you want in the future.
- Evaluate Your Budget
- If you need a cost-effective replacement now, asphalt shingles deliver excellent short-term value.
- If you can invest more upfront, metal roofs pay off over time with lower maintenance and fewer replacements.
- Consider Your Climate
- Cold, snowy, or coastal climates benefit most from the durability of metal roofing.
- Milder regions with less extreme weather may not need that extra strength, making shingles more practical.
- Think About Longevity
- Planning to stay for decades? Choose metal.
- Selling soon? Asphalt might be the smarter financial move.
- Check HOA or Neighborhood Rules
- Some communities restrict reflective or metal finishes. Always confirm before deciding.
- Factor in Resale Value
- While both materials can improve resale value, homes with metal roofing often stand out thanks to energy savings and low upkeep.
Final Thoughts on Metal vs Shingle Roofing
When comparing metal roofs vs asphalt shingles, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer—only the best fit for your goals, budget, and home.
- Choose asphalt shingles if affordability, style variety, and quick installation are your top priorities.
- Choose metal roofing if you value long-term protection, energy savings, and a “once-in-a-lifetime” upgrade.
Either way, your roof is one of your home’s most important investments. Working with an experienced, certified team ensures it performs beautifully for years to come.
For homeowners across New Hampshire, Northern Massachusetts, and Southern Maine, Adam Vaillancourt Roofing is the trusted local expert in both asphalt and metal systems.
As an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred and CertainTeed Select Shingle Master contractor, their team provides the highest quality materials, craftsmanship, and honest recommendations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to have a metal roof or shingles?
It depends on your long-term goals. If you want the most cost-effective option upfront, asphalt shingles are ideal. But if you’re looking for longevity, energy efficiency, and minimal maintenance, metal roofing typically provides a better return over time. Both can be excellent choices when installed by a qualified professional.
Does a metal roof lower your insurance?
In some cases, yes. Because metal roofs are fire-resistant and durable, many insurance companies offer policy discounts. Always check with your provider, as coverage and savings vary by state and policy type.
How many years will a metal roof last?
A professionally installed metal roof can last between 40 and 70 years, depending on the material, maintenance, and local climate. By contrast, asphalt shingles typically last 20 to 30 years before replacement is needed.
Do metal roofs affect cell service?
No, not significantly. Metal can reflect radio signals, but it rarely blocks cellular reception. Factors like tower proximity, insulation, and home layout have a greater impact on signal quality than roofing materials.
